[amaybaum]

Records-only correction. Reviewed; waiting for green CI.

• Authorization:
  • Initial approval: owner, chat 2026-11-08, recorded at OI-QM-EXT-1: establish conditional equivalence with explicit added conditions, then minimize and source them #1169 c.6719712698.
  • Scope widened: owner option A, chat 2026-11-08, recorded at OI-QM-EXT-1: establish conditional equivalence with explicit added conditions, then minimize and source them #1169 c.6719814192. "Correct DESIGN.md:21 alongside the two previously approved lines. Leave the two closing sentences unchanged, but explain in the PR description that their independent-review requirement has already been satisfied. … No additional scope expansion."
• Head: f6570e9b0696d35daa97e043cb64b3a46a894af0, based on main f88c1842. It changes one line in each of three files.

Changes

Each line said "review pending". Each now cites the #1189 reviews:

independently model-reviewed: ACCEPT at 1f992246 (#1189 c.6713700281) and delta ACCEPT at 8ca8ce30, the reviewed content (#1189 c.6713781034)

1. quarter-phase-feedback-20261107/RESULT.md:3. "WIP / author paper result" is kept.
2. quarter-phase-native-20261107/PROOF-RECOVERY.md:3. "WIP" is kept.
3. quarter-phase-native-20261107/DESIGN.md:21. This is the heading of the "Forward proof recovery" note. Q-A: feedback control boundary and paper proof repairs #1189 reviewed that recovery's forward changes to DESIGN; Q-A: can OI natively produce the quarter-phase mechanism? (#1169 step 3) #1184 reviewed the original Q-A DESIGN.

Left unchanged by owner decision

• RESULT.md:188–189: "Independent review of the exact pushed paper is required before its author result can be treated as accepted".
• PROOF-RECOVERY.md:212: "Independent review of the exact pushed forward patch is required".

Both sentences state a general requirement. The #1189 reviews cited above satisfy it. The sentences do not mean review is still pending.

Evidence

• Landing: Q-A: feedback control boundary and paper proof repairs #1189 landed all three files as merge 313a93ef, with parents 499463f0 and 8ca8ce30.
• Review coverage:
  • c.6713700281 gives a full ACCEPT at 1f992246 and covers RESULT, PROOF-RECOVERY and DESIGN.
  • c.6713781034 gives a delta ACCEPT at exactly 8ca8ce30.
• Byte identity: all three files on main are byte-identical to 8ca8ce30.
• Reviewer: a model subagent (/root/feedback_review), separate from the author. Hence "model-reviewed".
• Legacy records: none of the three files is in legacy-records.json.

Review of this PR

• First head 3e52882b: ACCEPT WITH CHANGES.
  • F1 is applied.
  • F2 is handled by the owner's decision above.
  • F3 is resolved: the initial approval is recorded at OI-QM-EXT-1: establish conditional equivalence with explicit added conditions, then minimize and source them #1169 c.6719712698.
• Final head f6570e9b: ACCEPT WITH CHANGES. Its one item, F4, asked that the option-A decision be recorded; it is now at c.6719814192. The diff needed no change.

Not authorized: merge. That needs green CI, then a separate owner decision.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_013T6pfKuv5mi3MXtKjH2tZb

[amaybaum]

Merge record: #1199 (owner-approved, chat, 2026-11-08)

The owner (amaybaum) approved this in chat with the coordinating session on 2026-11-08: "Approve #1199 merge and #1198 integration".

#1199 — Review-status corrections — Approve normal merge — Verify the three reviewed line changes against current main

Before proceeding, confirm green post-merge main CI for #1202.

Merged as f28eb29f26d450808c8d84d49e29294a59f59a94, a merge commit with parents 45eea51d and f6570e9b.

Checks before the merge:

• Reviewed head: f6570e9b, unchanged.
• Delta against current main 45eea51d: exactly the three reviewed status lines. They are in quarter-phase-feedback-20261107/RESULT.md:3, quarter-phase-native-20261107/PROOF-RECOVERY.md:3 and quarter-phase-native-20261107/DESIGN.md:21, with 3 lines added and 3 removed.
• Merge: clean.
• Main CI on 45eea51d (the A5-Q3: does any A6 extension to affine offsets (E1–E3) have independent justification? (#1049) #1202 merge): green, with 25 successes and 1 skip, on the owner-approved retry of run 42477331971. The earlier attempts failed only at the elan installer download (HTTP 504).
• PR CI on the head: run 42467235987, 25 successes and 1 skip.

Scope: status-line corrections only. They record that the quarter-phase records were independently model-reviewed (ACCEPT at 1f992246 and delta ACCEPT at 8ca8ce30, #1189 c.6713700281 and c.6713781034). No result, verdict or manuscript changes. Main's push CI is running and will be reported here.

---

Generated by Claude Code