You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
What did the interview on the talk already settle? #15652
Seed for the talk's map: record what the interview on the ecosystem-specifics and ladder Brief already settled, so no session on the map asks it again. The resolution comment lists every answered question and the Brief's acceptance criteria.
I understood this as a seed task for the talk's map (see #15651). It asks for a record of the questions the interview on the ecosystem-specifics and ladder Brief already answered, so later sessions on the map don't ask them again. The resolution comment it points to should list each answered question and the Brief's acceptance criteria.
The issue doesn't say where the record should live, such as a map file or an issue comment. That is an implementation choice and doesn't need an owner decision. I found no duplicate among the open issues and no merged pull request that already covers it.
Not admitted to the issue lane yet: no trusted-human acceptance criteria: a listed human must put the confirmed - [ ] criteria in the body or post them as their own comment, or, on an issue a listed human filed, intake's newest refinement comment must hold them unedited; intake's refinement of this body is due and may supply them.
Resolved: the interview settled the answers below (owner, 2026-11-12, six rounds). Basis: the interview's open-question register; "as recommended" means the owner accepted the recommendation put to him.
Answered questions
Q1. Do the six working terms (executed adapter, model-read guidance, detection control, sensitivity control, ecosystem record, security and safety floor) mean what the owner means? Yes, as recommended, provided the decisions stay aligned with the talk and authoritative research.
Q2. Does "no shipped language specifics" cover model-read guidance only, leaving executed code in place? Yes, model-read guidance only.
Q3. Do executed adapters stay? Yes, each required to name what it cannot read.
Q4. Do the 16 plugins named for one tool stay as they are? Yes.
Q5. Do the per-language security-review checklists and the install allowlist stay? Yes, as security and safety floors.
Q6. Does a language-flavored example stay? Yes, when its rule survives a tool swap and it is not in a tool-picking step.
Q7. Is a whole-page deletion proven with a sensitivity control (a run with the page replaced by a plausible but wrong version)? Yes.
Q8. Is the live-app exploring skill built and proven against a fixture app in this repository first, with a real consumer app as a later trial the owner runs? Yes, fixture first.
Q9. Should the worktree rule read "never remove a worktree this session did not create"? Yes.
Q10. Does the sensitivity control apply only to whole-page deletions, with the detection control unchanged for every other cut? Yes; the four rule statements gain one clause, nothing replaced.
Q11. Is the enforcement ladder the one representation of the talk's pyramid, gaining a verification tier between static analysis and guidance? Yes; the rungs inside the new tier go to design.
Q12. Does the ladder state the proportion (most enforcement in the strongest tiers, least in guidance and human review) in words with no numeric target? Yes.
Q13. Does the automation-gaps audit report, read-only, how a repository's enforcement is spread across the tiers? Yes: counts per tier and rules that sit lower than they could, no target.
Q14. Does the alignment sweep cover only skills that recommend, place or build enforcement or an instruction, with a review rule for new skills? Yes.
Q15. Does toolchain stop running its bundled default commands? Yes; inference from build files stays.
Q16. Does the plugin philosophy gain an exception: a port whose adapter is the consumer's own tool ships no default adapter and reports the capability unresolved? Yes.
Q17. Superseded by Q32.
Q18. May an unattended lane run commands the repository states or its build files imply, with no person confirming? Yes, within limits: no install, no CI step text, no record write, each command logged as assumed with its source; an unsure run counts as unattended.
Q19. Superseded by Q30.
Q20. Does the Brief cover only the ecosystem-specifics migration and the ladder alignment, with the other decided efforts as separate work items? Yes.
Q30. Does a lane's record pull request hold only commands a lane may already run under the unattended limits, checked mechanically? Yes; a deterministic check refuses anything else, and "a merged pull request counts as acceptance" is added for ecosystem records only.
Q31. Does retiring bundled defaults apply wherever a shipped default picks a tool or a command, not only in toolchain? Yes; a default that picks neither is untouched.
Q32. Does a shipped default that picks a library for the consumer also go? Yes: discover from the repository's own dependencies, else ask when attended or report unresolved in a lane.
Q33. Does the pyramid-alignment requirement apply only to the skills in the sweep's scope? Yes, skills that recommend, place or build enforcement or an instruction.
Q34. Does organization-level context reach a skill through the repository's own synced standards, with no new organization layer? Yes.
Q35. Are the session's coined names working names only? Yes; final names are chosen in design.
Q36. Are mechanism-level decisions settled at design and planning, not in the interview? Yes.
Q37. Where does the verification tier sit in the proportion rule? Third, after codebase and static analysis, before guidance and human review (the talk's slide 8 order).
Q38. Which wins, the design's rewrite of the four rule statements or the narrower proof rule? The narrower rule (Q10).
Q39. Are the design panel's judge scores verified? Yes, read from the workflow result.
Q43. Does the sensitivity control rest on authoritative research? No outside source defines it; the owner accepted it knowing that, and it is a named assumption.
Q44. Is "an unsure run counts as unattended" still open? No, Q18 decided it.
Q45. Is every talk topic outside the Brief tracked as its own item under one parent, each undecided one at its menu recommendation, with her order of work added as a rule? Yes; charted as this map.
The Brief's acceptance criteria
AC1: No generic skill ships a model-read tool, library or command choice outside the named exceptions, and the portability gate, widened to agents and plugin-level reference and context files, passes.
AC2: The enforcement ladder has no tool-named rung id, has a verification tier in third position, states the proportion in words with no numeric target, states her order of work (lint first, clean up, strengthen verification, then automate), and its five copies are in sync.
AC3: Codify no longer routes a pytest testing/audit/ finding to a C#-specific tutorial, and its proposal names the fix-message requirement and hands the build to /implementation:implement.
AC4: Toolchain runs no bundled default command; a repository with no record and nothing inferable shows a visible unresolved skip; a source file outside every ecosystem is named, not skipped silently.
AC5: An unattended run executes only stated or inferred commands, logs each as assumed with its source, installs nothing, writes no record, and reports a tie as unresolved.
AC6: A lane's record pull request containing a command outside the unattended limits is refused by a deterministic check.
AC7: Each whole-page deletion carries a sensitivity-control result; each partial cut carries a detection-control result.
AC8: Each executed adapter names a file or value it cannot read, and an unlisted mutation tool value is accepted and reported as having no shipped adapter.
AC9: The automation-gaps audit reports, read-only, a count per ladder tier and the rules that sit lower than they could.
AC10: A review rule holds every new skill that recommends, places or builds enforcement or an instruction to read the ladder, prefer the strongest tier that can decide the matter, and discover the consumer's tooling first.
AC11: This repository's own ecosystem records exist, and its /toolchain:check command list on a fixed diff is identical before and after the change.
Deferred to design or planning, not settled here: how a skill with no ladder copy reads the ladder; whether the rule-to-enforcer inventory and the per-tier count are one artifact; whether the resolution procedure needs its own contract; ladder version sequencing; the live-app fixture's stack and home; models and runs per compare; the classifier agreement threshold; alias lifetime and cut order; final public names; which skill writes a lane-proposed record; whether toolchain's bundled files are deleted or kept as shape examples; which plugins hold the synced resolution text.
Activity
github-actions commentedon Nov 12, 2026
Size: Small
Complexity: Low
Uncertainty: Knowable
Flags: none
Blocked by: none
I understood this as a seed task for the talk's map (see #15651). It asks for a record of the questions the interview on the ecosystem-specifics and ladder Brief already answered, so later sessions on the map don't ask them again. The resolution comment it points to should list each answered question and the Brief's acceptance criteria.
The issue doesn't say where the record should live, such as a map file or an issue comment. That is an implementation choice and doesn't need an owner decision. I found no duplicate among the open issues and no merged pull request that already covers it.
Automated triage. A maintainer reviews it.
melodic-automation-lanes commentedon Nov 12, 2026
Not admitted to the issue lane yet: no trusted-human acceptance criteria: a listed human must put the confirmed
- [ ]criteria in the body or post them as their own comment, or, on an issue a listed human filed, intake's newest refinement comment must hold them unedited; intake's refinement of this body is due and may supply them.kyle-sexton commentedon Nov 12, 2026
Resolved: the interview settled the answers below (owner, 2026-11-12, six rounds). Basis: the interview's open-question register; "as recommended" means the owner accepted the recommendation put to him.
Answered questions
The Brief's acceptance criteria
testing/audit/finding to a C#-specific tutorial, and its proposal names the fix-message requirement and hands the build to/implementation:implement./toolchain:checkcommand list on a fixed diff is identical before and after the change.Deferred to design or planning, not settled here: how a skill with no ladder copy reads the ladder; whether the rule-to-enforcer inventory and the per-tier count are one artifact; whether the resolution procedure needs its own contract; ladder version sequencing; the live-app fixture's stack and home; models and runs per compare; the classifier agreement threshold; alias lifetime and cut order; final public names; which skill writes a lane-proposed record; whether toolchain's bundled files are deleted or kept as shape examples; which plugins hold the synced resolution text.
kyle-sexton commentedon Nov 12, 2026
Done (2026-11-12): Resolved; see the resolution comment.