Skip to content

feat: support Nextrade app reviews in Firstmate - #53

Merged
knowttl merged 5 commits into
mainfrom
fm/nx-rw-2d-firstmate-adapter
Oct 1, 2026
Merged

feat: support Nextrade app reviews in Firstmate#53
knowttl merged 5 commits into
mainfrom
fm/nx-rw-2d-firstmate-adapter

Conversation

@knowttl

@knowttl knowttl commented Oct 1, 2026 •
edited
Loading

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Nextrade’s in-app experiment reviews could not participate in Firstmate’s captain-hold lifecycle because the review adapter supported Lavish boards only.
Without an app adapter, app feedback and answered decisions would not reach the hosting task or release its keyed holds through the shared lifecycle.
This change adds the Nextrade adapter and routes its captured results through the existing inbox, acknowledgement, and captain-hold owners.

Scope: the adapter polls in the hosting task’s target context and may post its staged agent reply; it never answers or consumes an app decision.
Reconciliation and wakes remain owned by the generic runner, and the Lavish adapter remains available for design reviews.
Acceptance covers adapter/stub-server regressions and six live CLI/API scenarios.
The real Workspace-page round (ask a decision through the CLI, answer it on the page, and release the held task through fm-captain-hold.sh answers) is deferred to the programme W4 acceptance run because slice 2b’s Workspace page is not yet built.

Intent

The captain commissioned the in-app research workflows programme for nextrade, which moves the backtester-optimization and strategy-experiment review loops from Lavish boards into the nextrade app, and authorized dispatching each slice without a per-stage ask ("you can begin dispatching the in-app research workflow builds without needing my approval for each stage"), then on 2026-10-01: "please dispatch the builds now and anything that can run in parallel please do so."
This is slice 2d of that plan: the firstmate adapter, so firstmate's captain-hold lifecycle keeps working when a review runs in the app instead of on a Lavish board.
Its dependency, nextrade slice 1b (experiment messages, listener lease, inbox poll: https://github.com/knowttl/nextrade/pull/1111), has landed; slice 1a (decisions and arm verdicts: https://github.com/knowttl/nextrade/pull/1090) has landed too.

What Changed

  • Add a Nextrade experiment adapter that polls in the hosting task’s target context, posts staged replies, and delivers app review feedback through the existing task inbox and acknowledgement lifecycle.
  • Feed captain-answered app decisions into the shared captain-hold intake, preserving close modes and separate reconciliation requests.
  • Document app-backed review operation, add adapter regression coverage and test-runner routing, and support subreaper environments in the orphan-listener test.

Risk Assessment

✅ Low: The adapter is bounded, reuses existing lifecycle controls, and matches the pinned Nextrade contracts without a substantiated material defect.

Testing

All three reported current-head automated regressions passed without skips; these do not establish a live scenario result. Six earlier live CLI/API passes from this run are preserved. No implementation changes were made. Workspace UI was not tested and has no visual evidence because slice 2b is unavailable; its W4 deferral is explicitly accepted.

  • Live validation: ✅ go - 6 of 8 scenarios driven live against the product
Scenario Result Live Evidence
Stage a review reply, rejecting empty replies and duplicate active registration ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: empty reply refused without registration; accepted reply posted once; duplicate arm refused
Answer a keyed app decision through the API and release the matching held task ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: captain API answer captured, delivered to task inbox, and recorded as released; consumed_at remains null
Continue a review and retain ownership until its final round is acknowledged ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: nonterminal re-arm succeeds; premature retirement refused; terminal acknowledgement retires the source
Capture a final free-text answer and close its question with Unicode text preserved ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: final answered batch closes question and preserves café answer text
Request reconciliation without releasing work, and prevent ordinary prose from resolving tasks ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: reconciliation request filed while recheck and prose-task remain held
Attempt to listen while another reviewer owns the inbox without displacing that reviewer ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: HTTP_409 listener_active delivered as actionable feedback; other-review retains its lease
Run focused adapter, shared review-runner, and captain-hold lifecycle regressions ⏸️ untested no The prior payload records automated regression checks that include stubs and explicitly marks them live=false. It therefore does not establish a live product result for this scenario; the reported reg…
Answer through the Workspace page and observe captain-hold release ⏸️ untested no Slice 2b's Workspace page is unavailable. Earlier validation drove the real public decision API instead. The recorded human decision explicitly accepts deferral to programme W4, when the Workspace pag…
Evidence: Preserved live CLI/API evidence from earlier rounds of this run

Source: Preserved live CLI/API evidence from earlier rounds of this run

$ bin/fm-lab-home.sh create ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/home
~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/home

$ nextrade-axi experiment create --slug live-af99e8d9-bc07-45e8-a541-cfa77d91d30a --title Adapter review --json
{"id":"cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd","slug":"live-af99e8d9-bc07-45e8-a541-cfa77d91d30a","title":"Adapter review","status":"active","kind":"free_form","keep":false,"board_url":null,"notes":null,"hypothesis":null,"lifecycle_phase":null,"best_arm_id":null,"holdout_from":null,"search_start":null,"search_end":null,"holdout_end":null,"created_at":"2026-10-01T16:20:12.889221+00:00","ended_at":null,"expires_at":"2026-10-15T16:20:12.896674+00:00"}

$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh source-id cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd --for review
nextrade-af0a143a9e5a8d75a5c3133438ece230

$ tasks-axi add held-task Apply selected research arm --repo nextrade
ok: added held-task (repo nextrade) -> Queued
task:
  id: held-task
  title: Apply selected research arm
  state: queued
  blocked: no
  blocked_by: none
  held: no
  hold_reason: "-"
  hold_kind: "-"
  hold_until: "-"
  kind: task
  repo: nextrade
  priority: "-"
  created: 2026-10-01
  closed: "-"
  deps: none
  links: none
  body: ""
help[2]:
  - Run `tasks-axi start held-task` to move it to in flight
  - Run `tasks-axi block held-task --by <other>` to record a dependency

$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-captain-hold.sh hold held-task --reason Select the research arm
held-task

$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-captain-hold.sh bind nextrade-af0a143a9e5a8d75a5c3133438ece230
bound: nextrade-af0a143a9e5a8d75a5c3133438ece230 -> (any)

POST /experiments/cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd/decisions
{"key": "held-task", "title": "Select arm", "explanation": "Choose the next research step", "options": [{"value": "adopt", "label": "Adopt café arm", "consequence": "Continue"}, {"value": "reject", "label": "Reject arm", "consequence": "Search again"}], "recommendation": "adopt", "example": "Continue the selected arm", "phase": null, "close_mode": "release", "id": "06e2fa88-6a62-4e41-b4e2-62c62bcb6ce7", "experiment_id": "cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd", "asked_by": "agent", "asked_at": "2026-10-01T16:20:14.414948Z", "status": "open", "selection": null, "answer_text": null, "answered_by": null, "answered_at": null, "answer_delivered_at": null, "consumed_at": null}
$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh arm cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd --for review --agent-reply-file ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/blank.md
error: Nextrade did not accept the staged reply: error: reply file is empty
code: VALIDATION_ERROR
error: cannot arm source nextrade-af0a143a9e5a8d75a5c3133438ece230: its staged reply was not delivered

Reply refusal: no source registered, app decision remains open.
$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh arm cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd --for review --agent-reply-file ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/reply.md
registered: nextrade-af0a143a9e5a8d75a5c3133438ece230 (nextrade, task=review)
armed: nextrade-af0a143a9e5a8d75a5c3133438ece230
experiment: cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd
owner-task: review

$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh arm cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd --for review --agent-reply-file ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/reply.md
error: cannot re-arm source nextrade-af0a143a9e5a8d75a5c3133438ece230: task review already holds this board and no captured round is waiting to be acknowledged

GET /experiments/cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd/messages?experiments=only
[{"id": "8f41d6b9-11e3-4dc9-9e45-28bfb34c8add", "experiment_id": "cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd", "kind": "message", "author": "agent", "body": "Review staged: café research.\n", "refs": null, "created_at": "2026-10-01T16:20:15.016152Z", "delivered_at": null}]
GET /experiments/cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd/decisions/06e2fa88-6a62-4e41-b4e2-62c62bcb6ce7
{"key": "held-task", "title": "Select arm", "explanation": "Choose the next research step", "options": [{"value": "adopt", "label": "Adopt café arm", "consequence": "Continue"}, {"value": "reject", "label": "Reject arm", "consequence": "Search again"}], "recommendation": "adopt", "example": "Continue the selected arm", "phase": null, "close_mode": "release", "id": "06e2fa88-6a62-4e41-b4e2-62c62bcb6ce7", "experiment_id": "cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd", "asked_by": "agent", "asked_at": "2026-10-01T16:20:14.414948Z", "status": "open", "selection": null, "answer_text": null, "answered_by": null, "answered_at": null, "answer_delivered_at": null, "consumed_at": null}
POST /experiments/cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd/decisions/06e2fa88-6a62-4e41-b4e2-62c62bcb6ce7/answer
{"key": "held-task", "title": "Select arm", "explanation": "Choose the next research step", "options": [{"value": "adopt", "label": "Adopt café arm", "consequence": "Continue"}, {"value": "reject", "label": "Reject arm", "consequence": "Search again"}], "recommendation": "adopt", "example": "Continue the selected arm", "phase": null, "close_mode": "release", "id": "06e2fa88-6a62-4e41-b4e2-62c62bcb6ce7", "experiment_id": "cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd", "asked_by": "agent", "asked_at": "2026-10-01T16:20:14.414948Z", "status": "answered", "selection": "adopt", "answer_text": "Keep café evidence", "answered_by": "captain", "answered_at": "2026-10-01T16:20:15.712846Z", "answer_delivered_at": null, "consumed_at": null}
$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh read ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/home/state/procevent-inbox/nextrade-af0a143a9e5a8d75a5c3133438ece230.1.result
end: false
messages: 0
decisions_answered: 1
decision: 06e2fa88-6a62-4e41-b4e2-62c62bcb6ce7 held-task answered release
title:
  | Select arm
explanation:
  | Choose the next research step
example:
  | Continue the selected arm
selection:
  | adopt
answer_text:
  | Keep café evidence
options: [{"consequence":"Continue","value":"adopt","label":"Adopt café arm"},{"consequence":"Search again","label":"Reject arm","value":"reject"}]

schema=fm-task-inbox.v1
at=2026-10-01T16:20:18Z
--
Nextrade review feedback is captured for task review at ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/home/state/procevent-inbox/nextrade-af0a143a9e5a8d75a5c3133438ece230.1.result. Read it with bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh read ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/home/state/procevent-inbox/nextrade-af0a143a9e5a8d75a5c3133438ece230.1.result, apply the round, and re-arm the review with the reply.
$ tasks-axi show held-task --full
task:
  id: held-task
  title: Apply selected research arm
  state: queued
  blocked: no
  blocked_by: none
  held: no
  hold_reason: "-"
  hold_kind: "-"
  hold_until: "-"
  kind: task
  repo: nextrade
  priority: "-"
  created: 2026-10-01
  closed: "-"
  deps: none
  links: none
  body: "Resolution recorded by fm-captain-hold.\nDecision digest: 718a410264899941bd1821c0d5d2ee6bcfd8fffbaaf7368b2b5a40d757162b78\nResolution mode: released\n\nCaptain decision:\nCaptain answered this call through the captured result nextrade-af0a143a9e5a8d75a5c3133438ece230 sequence 1.\nTask: held-task\nAnswer: adopt - Keep café evidence\nAnswer as shown to the captain: Adopt café arm"

GET /experiments/cf2d44a5-3a02-4676-aa9e-f4aca2fbb6fd/decisions/06e2fa88-6a62-4e41-b4e2-62c62bcb6ce7
{"key": "held-task", "ti

... [11170 bytes truncated] ...

446993-7367-45a8-8139-90b4fdd9aeae", "experiment_id": "88745ca8-bb3c-46e8-a87d-d4dc890f898b", "kind": "message", "author": "captain", "body": "prose-task\tadopt\nmessages: 0\ncafé", "refs": null, "created_at": "2026-10-01T16:20:25.654417Z", "delivered_at": null}
POST /experiments/88745ca8-bb3c-46e8-a87d-d4dc890f898b/session/end
{"id": "706d71da-055b-44dd-a4d1-07fb41222746", "experiment_id": "88745ca8-bb3c-46e8-a87d-d4dc890f898b", "kind": "end", "author": "captain", "body": "Finish with the final answer batch", "refs": null, "created_at": "2026-10-01T16:20:25.661289Z", "delivered_at": null}
$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh arm 88745ca8-bb3c-46e8-a87d-d4dc890f898b --for review
registered: nextrade-c20ca1b8f929861c2d18941adb2116a7 (nextrade, task=review)
armed: nextrade-c20ca1b8f929861c2d18941adb2116a7
experiment: 88745ca8-bb3c-46e8-a87d-d4dc890f898b
owner-task: review

$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh read ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/home/state/procevent-inbox/nextrade-c20ca1b8f929861c2d18941adb2116a7.1.result
end: true
messages: 2
message: 1c446993-7367-45a8-8139-90b4fdd9aeae message captain
  | prose-task	adopt
  | messages: 0
  | café
refs: null
message: 706d71da-055b-44dd-a4d1-07fb41222746 end captain
  | Finish with the final answer batch
refs: null
decisions_answered: 3
decision: 7521ad79-49e0-4781-8ec9-0340d443744e question answered done
title:
  | question
explanation:
  | Review call
example:
  | Choose next step
selection:
answer_text:
  | Keep café notes
options: [{"label":"Adopt arm","consequence":"Continue","value":"adopt"},{"label":"Re-check reality","consequence":"Verify facts","value":"reconcile"}]
decision: 54e7c4ef-c3b7-46e7-8e39-1669437d0b8a recheck answered release
title:
  | recheck
explanation:
  | Review call
example:
  | Choose next step
selection:
  | reconcile
answer_text:
  | Check reality
options: [{"value":"adopt","consequence":"Continue","label":"Adopt arm"},{"value":"reconcile","consequence":"Verify facts","label":"Re-check reality"}]
decision: 2bfde0e4-4cc7-4abc-8e1e-2ae95aab77c9 absent-task answered release
title:
  | absent-task
explanation:
  | Review call
example:
  | Choose next step
selection:
  | adopt
answer_text:
  | No matching held task
options: [{"value":"adopt","consequence":"Continue","label":"Adopt arm"},{"label":"Re-check reality","consequence":"Verify facts","value":"reconcile"}]

$ tasks-axi show question --full
task:
  id: question
  title: question
  state: done
  blocked: no
  blocked_by: none
  held: no
  hold_reason: Captain call question
  hold_kind: captain
  hold_until: "-"
  kind: task
  repo: nextrade
  priority: "-"
  created: "-"
  closed: 2026-10-01
  deps: none
  links: none
  body: "Resolution recorded by fm-captain-hold.\nDecision digest: 2177f5f7e045ef0f491d4ab36953eb0994fcb62b80b29daef207eef17648531b\nResolution mode: answered\n\nCaptain decision:\nCaptain answered this call through the captured result nextrade-c20ca1b8f929861c2d18941adb2116a7 sequence 1.\nTask: question\nAnswer: Keep café notes"

$ tasks-axi show recheck --full
task:
  id: recheck
  title: recheck
  state: queued
  blocked: no
  blocked_by: none
  held: yes
  hold_reason: Captain call recheck
  hold_kind: captain
  hold_until: "-"
  kind: task
  repo: nextrade
  priority: "-"
  created: 2026-10-01
  closed: "-"
  deps: none
  links: none
  body: "Captain hold set: 2026-10-01T16:20:22Z"

$ tasks-axi show prose-task --full
task:
  id: prose-task
  title: prose-task
  state: queued
  blocked: no
  blocked_by: none
  held: yes
  hold_reason: Captain call prose-task
  hold_kind: captain
  hold_until: "-"
  kind: task
  repo: nextrade
  priority: "-"
  created: 2026-10-01
  closed: "-"
  deps: none
  links: none
  body: "Captain hold set: 2026-10-01T16:20:24Z"

$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-captain-hold.sh reconcile list
recheck	requested=2026-10-01T16:20:27Z	source=the captured result nextrade-c20ca1b8f929861c2d18941adb2116a7 sequence 1
reconcile-requests: 1

$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent.sh handled nextrade-c20ca1b8f929861c2d18941adb2116a7 1
handled: nextrade-c20ca1b8f929861c2d18941adb2116a7 1
retired: nextrade-c20ca1b8f929861c2d18941adb2116a7 (owner acknowledged its terminal round)

PASS: final answered batch closes the question, files reconciliation without release, and prose releases nothing.
$ nextrade-axi experiment create --slug lease-88eb9e6b-145f-4bd2-9ba3-22762c7baf70 --title Listener guard --json
{"id":"137f303d-3f95-40a3-9fba-4b9bd2997b21","slug":"lease-88eb9e6b-145f-4bd2-9ba3-22762c7baf70","title":"Listener guard","status":"active","kind":"free_form","keep":false,"board_url":null,"notes":null,"hypothesis":null,"lifecycle_phase":null,"best_arm_id":null,"holdout_from":null,"search_start":null,"search_end":null,"holdout_end":null,"created_at":"2026-10-01T16:20:30.384086+00:00","ended_at":null,"expires_at":"2026-10-15T16:20:30.386193+00:00"}

$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh source-id 137f303d-3f95-40a3-9fba-4b9bd2997b21 --for review
nextrade-29a7efbc8c830d38ae444f6c7b604e71

GET /experiments/137f303d-3f95-40a3-9fba-4b9bd2997b21/inbox?owner=other-review&wait=0
{"messages": [], "decisions_answered": [], "end": false, "cursor": "eyJleHBlcmltZW50IjogIjEzN2YzMDNkLTNmOTUtNDBhMy05ZmJhLTRiOWJkMjk5N2IyMSIsICJtZXNzYWdlcyI6IG51bGwsICJkZWNpc2lvbnMiOiBudWxsfQ==", "listener": {"owner": "other-review", "expires_at": "2026-10-01T16:21:00.423054Z"}}
$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh arm 137f303d-3f95-40a3-9fba-4b9bd2997b21 --for review
registered: nextrade-29a7efbc8c830d38ae444f6c7b604e71 (nextrade, task=review)
armed: nextrade-29a7efbc8c830d38ae444f6c7b604e71
experiment: 137f303d-3f95-40a3-9fba-4b9bd2997b21
owner-task: review

error: "Listener other-review holds the inbox until 2026-10-01T16:21:00.423054+00:00"
code: HTTP_409
operation: "GET /experiments/{experiment_id}/inbox"
reason_code: listener_active

$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh classify ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/home/state/procevent-inbox/nextrade-29a7efbc8c830d38ae444f6c7b604e71.1.result
unknown

$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh terminal ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/home/state/procevent-inbox/nextrade-29a7efbc8c830d38ae444f6c7b604e71.1.result

GET /experiments/137f303d-3f95-40a3-9fba-4b9bd2997b21/listener
{"experiment_id": "137f303d-3f95-40a3-9fba-4b9bd2997b21", "owner": "other-review", "acquired_at": "2026-10-01T16:20:30.423054Z", "expires_at": "2026-10-01T16:21:00.423054Z"}
schema=fm-task-inbox.v1
at=2026-10-01T16:20:31Z
--
Nextrade review feedback is captured for task review at ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/home/state/procevent-inbox/nextrade-29a7efbc8c830d38ae444f6c7b604e71.1.result. Read it with bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh read ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/.test-nx-lab/home/state/procevent-inbox/nextrade-29a7efbc8c830d38ae444f6c7b604e71.1.result, apply the round, and re-arm the review with the reply.
$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent.sh handled nextrade-29a7efbc8c830d38ae444f6c7b604e71 1
handled: nextrade-29a7efbc8c830d38ae444f6c7b604e71 1

$ ~/.no-mistakes/worktrees/37ca4d16e8c5/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/bin/fm-procevent-nextrade.sh retire 137f303d-3f95-40a3-9fba-4b9bd2997b21 --for review
retired: nextrade-29a7efbc8c830d38ae444f6c7b604e71

PASS: lease conflict stays actionable and never displaces the existing listener.

Pipeline

Updates from git push no-mistakes

✅ **intent** - passed

✅ No issues found.

✅ **Rebase** - passed

✅ No issues found.

✅ **Review** - passed

✅ No issues found.

🔧 **Test** - 2 issues found → auto-fixed → no changes applied ✅
  • ⚠️ tests/fm-procevent.test.sh:3834 - The pre-existing shared-runner test requires an orphan listener's parent to be PID 1. This host correctly reparents orphans to systemd --user, PID 1076, independently confirmed by a process probe. The assertion stops the regression before its remaining lifecycle checks. A private PID-namespace workaround was denied at /proc/self/uid_map. Make the test verify reparenting without assuming PID 1, or run it on a compatible host.
  • ⚠️ live validation verdict: inconclusive (6 of 8 scenarios were driven live against the product); untested: Complete the shared review-runner regression, including orphan cleanup, Answer through the app Workspace page and observe captain-hold release
  • Live validation: ⚠️ inconclusive - 6 of 8 scenarios driven live against the product
Scenario Result Live Evidence
Arm a review from its hosting task and receive results in that task's inbox ✅ pass live Live Nextrade CLI, API, and task-state transcript
Reject an empty staged reply and duplicate arming without posting another reply ✅ pass live Live Nextrade CLI, API, and task-state transcript
Answer an app decision and release matching work with Unicode wording preserved and the app decision unconsumed ✅ pass live Live Nextrade CLI, API, and task-state transcript
Re-arm after feedback and require acknowledgement before retiring the terminal review ✅ pass live Live Nextrade CLI, API, and task-state transcript
Deliver final answers, close a question, retain reconciliation work, and ignore answer-shaped prose ✅ pass live Live Nextrade CLI, API, and task-state transcript
Encounter another listener's lease without taking it over or suppressing the conflict ✅ pass live Live Nextrade CLI, API, and task-state transcript
Complete the shared review-runner regression, including orphan cleanup ⏸️ untested no The prior payload did not establish a live result: the regression used stand-in sources and stopped on its PID-1 environment assumption before completing lifecycle checks. A private PID namespace was…
Answer through the app Workspace page and observe captain-hold release ⏸️ untested no Downloaded the real Nextrade source and ran its backend locally, but the experiment Workspace page is absent. The real public answer API proved release; the browser round requires the slice 2b Workspa…
  • bash bin/fm-test-run.sh tests/fm-procevent-nextrade.test.sh tests/fm-captain-hold-lifecycle.test.sh tests/fm-procevent.test.sh
  • git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/knowttl/nextrade.git .test-nextrade-stack
  • Workspace-local PostgreSQL initialization, startup, and shutdown using extracted PostgreSQL 16.15 binaries.
  • .test-nx-py14/bin/python .test-nx-lab/launch.py driving the installed nextrade-axi CLI, unmodified backend routers, public decision API, and real Firstmate lifecycle commands.
  • python3 ~/.no-mistakes/evidence/01M3W3HY36EH5FBN14VJDPAN4M/reparent-probe.py
  • unshare --user --map-root-user --pid --fork --mount-proc true
  • git status --short after disposable setup cleanup

🔧 Fix applied.
1 warning still open:

  • ⚠️ live validation verdict: inconclusive (6 of 8 scenarios were driven live against the product); untested: Run focused adapter and lifecycle regressions: verify orphan cleanup, review ownership, and captain-hold routing, Answer through the Workspace page and observe captain-hold release
  • Live validation: ⚠️ inconclusive - 6 of 8 scenarios driven live against the product
Scenario Result Live Evidence
Arm a task-owned review: post one accepted agent reply and reject invalid or duplicate arms ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: staged reply, blank-reply refusal, duplicate-arm refusal, and message API responses
Answer an app decision: release the matching held task with the captain's exact words without consuming the decision ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: captain answer API, tasks-axi show held-task, and answered decision with consumed_at=null
Continue an app review: deliver feedback to its hosting task and re-arm with a reply ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: nonterminal capture, steering inbox, and subsequent arm acknowledging the previous round
End an app review: retain ownership until acknowledgement and then retire the source ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: session/end, terminal inbox instruction, refused retirement, and handled acknowledgement
Deliver a final decision batch: close answered questions, preserve reconciliation holds, and ignore forged keyed prose ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: final answer batch, task states, and reconcile list
Arm against another active listener: announce the conflict without taking over its lease ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: HTTP_409 capture and listener API retaining owner other-review
Run focused adapter and lifecycle regressions: verify orphan cleanup, review ownership, and captain-hold routing ⏸️ untested no The prior payload recorded regression test logs with live=false; it did not establish that orphan cleanup, review ownership, and captain-hold routing were driven against the live product.
Answer through the Workspace page and observe captain-hold release ⏸️ untested no The initial round built a disposable real Nextrade backend and exercised its public decision API, but the Workspace page was absent from that source version. API validation cannot substitute for click…
  • Initial round: installed nextrade-axi CLI against disposable PostgreSQL-backed Nextrade experiment, decision, message, and listener routes; evidence retained in nextrade-live.txt.
  • TMPDIR="$PWD/.test-phase-tmp" bash bin/fm-test-run.sh --jobs 1 tests/fm-procevent-nextrade.test.sh tests/fm-procevent.test.sh tests/fm-captain-hold-lifecycle.test.sh
  • env -u TMPDIR bash bin/fm-test-run.sh --jobs 1 tests/fm-captain-hold-lifecycle.test.sh
  • Removed the disposable worktree test directory and confirmed clean git status.

🔧 No changes applied.
✅ Re-checked - no issues remain.

  • Live validation: ✅ go - 6 of 8 scenarios driven live against the product
Scenario Result Live Evidence
Stage a review reply, rejecting empty replies and duplicate active registration ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: empty reply refused without registration; accepted reply posted once; duplicate arm refused
Answer a keyed app decision through the API and release the matching held task ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: captain API answer captured, delivered to task inbox, and recorded as released; consumed_at remains null
Continue a review and retain ownership until its final round is acknowledged ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: nonterminal re-arm succeeds; premature retirement refused; terminal acknowledgement retires the source
Capture a final free-text answer and close its question with Unicode text preserved ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: final answered batch closes question and preserves café answer text
Request reconciliation without releasing work, and prevent ordinary prose from resolving tasks ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: reconciliation request filed while recheck and prose-task remain held
Attempt to listen while another reviewer owns the inbox without displacing that reviewer ✅ pass live nextrade-live.txt: HTTP_409 listener_active delivered as actionable feedback; other-review retains its lease
Run focused adapter, shared review-runner, and captain-hold lifecycle regressions ⏸️ untested no The prior payload records automated regression checks that include stubs and explicitly marks them live=false. It therefore does not establish a live product result for this scenario; the reported reg…
Answer through the Workspace page and observe captain-hold release ⏸️ untested no Slice 2b's Workspace page is unavailable. Earlier validation drove the real public decision API instead. The recorded human decision explicitly accepts deferral to programme W4, when the Workspace pag…
  • git rev-parse HEAD confirmed e0ac78dcf4c79d4464b238e055adb39b153a5cd8.
  • env -u TMPDIR bash bin/fm-test-run.sh tests/fm-procevent-nextrade.test.sh tests/fm-procevent.test.sh tests/fm-captain-hold-lifecycle.test.sh exited 0.
  • tests/fm-procevent-nextrade.test.sh: exit=0, duration_ms=13043, gate_skip=false.
  • tests/fm-procevent.test.sh: exit=0, duration_ms=330711, gate_skip=false.
  • tests/fm-captain-hold-lifecycle.test.sh: exit=0, duration_ms=433052, gate_skip=false.
  • Reviewed retained nextrade-live.txt and live-setup.md to preserve the six previously passing live CLI/API scenarios.
  • git status --short confirmed no working-tree changes after testing.
✅ **Document** - passed

✅ No issues found.

🔧 **Lint** - 1 issue found → auto-fixed ✅
  • ⚠️ linter found issues (exit code 1)

🔧 Fix applied.
✅ Re-checked - no issues remain.

✅ **Push** - passed

✅ No issues found.

knowttl added 5 commits October 1, 2026 09:00
@knowttl
Add Nextrade experiment review process-event adapter
9ad6fbf
@knowttl
no-mistakes(test): Fix orphan reparenting test for subreaper hosts
e0ac78d
@knowttl
no-mistakes(document): Correct Nextrade arming guidance and consolida…
0ef96ba 
…te verification references
@knowttl
no-mistakes(lint): Fix Nextrade test assertions flagged by ShellCheck
2bb302d
@knowttl
no-mistakes(ci): Captain, fixed SC2317 and SC2034 in tests/fm-proceve…
6eebd79 
…nt-nextrade.test.sh by removing redundant failure exits and using the retry counter in an arithmetic loop. Pinned ShellCheck 0.11.0 and git diff --check pass. Requested regressions all exit 0: Nextrade 12130 ms, procevent 316883 ms, captain-hold lifecycle 413995 ms. Runner: total=3 failed=0 skipped_gate=0; seven Beads capability cases skipped internally. Workspace UI remains untested and deferred to W4
@knowttl
knowttl merged commit 17715e8 into main Oct 1, 2026
19 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Reviewers

No reviews

Assignees

No one assigned

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Milestone

No milestone

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant

@knowttl