SonarCloud: shell script hygiene

964 open SonarCloud finding(s) in combsmith/.github, worst severity MAJOR. Generated by the org SonarCloud Audit.

View in SonarCloud →

Findings

Rule	Count	Representative message
shelldre:S7688	964	Use '[[' instead of '[' for conditional tests. The '[[' construct is safer and more featur

Affected files

scripts/compliance-audit.sh (183)
scripts/lib/agent-rate-limit.sh (107)
scripts/lib/canary-rollout.sh (71)
scripts/compliance-remediate.sh (38)
scripts/agent-rate-limit-gate.sh (36)
scripts/lib/push-protection.sh (34)
scripts/migrate-major-channels.sh (33)
scripts/apply-repo-settings.sh (30)
.github/scripts/add-to-project/classify-initiative.sh (26)
scripts/agents-md-cycle-log.sh (26)
scripts/sonarcloud-audit.sh (24)
scripts/apply-rulesets.sh (22)
scripts/automerge-standards-sync.sh (20)
scripts/standards-staleness.sh (20)
scripts/lib/gitignore-baseline.sh (19)
scripts/lib/standards-release.sh (19)
.github/scripts/add-to-project/lib.sh (18)
.github/scripts/feature-ideation/lib/gh-safe.sh (15)
scripts/compliance-retrigger.sh (15)
scripts/fix-ruleset-bypass.sh (13)

Priority

Labeled priority:major — mapped from this bucket's worst SonarCloud severity (MAJOR).

Acceptance

All findings in this workstream resolved to zero in SonarCloud
No behavior change; CI green
Real fixes (no blanket NOSONAR unless a confirmed false positive, noted inline)

Idempotent issue — updated automatically each audit run; auto-closed when the finding count reaches zero.

Dev-Lead Implementation Plan

Issue: #1193 — SonarCloud: shell script hygiene

Scope

Resolve shelldre shell-script hygiene findings across first-party scripts (scripts/**, .github/scripts/**) as behavior-preserving refactors, and exclude vendored third-party code (node_modules/**) from SonarCloud analysis so its findings stop being reported. No behavior change; existing bats suites are the regression net.

Approach & Priority (largest, safest wins first)

Vendored-code exclusion (config). The two node_modules/bats/lib/bats-core/*.bash files (55 findings) plus the S7684 (BATS_FORMATTER_TEST_DURATION) and S100 (bats_export_preprocess_source_*) findings all originate in vendored bats. Add sonar.exclusions=node_modules/** to the root sonar-project.properties — third-party code must not be edited or audited as ours.
S7688 [ → [[ (898 findings, dominant). Confirmed safe here: no binary -a/-o, no escaped \</\>, no unquoted-glob RHS in single brackets. Convert first-party test commands via a reviewed transformation, gated by shellcheck + bats.
Smaller mechanical rules: S7677 redirect errors to stderr (8), S1481 unused locals (2), S1135 TODO (2), S1066 merge nested if (5).
Semantic rules where safely doable: S131 default *) case (26), S7679 positional-param → local (86), S7682 explicit return (149, using bare return to preserve exit status), S1192 repeated-literal constants (28).

Implementation Checklist

sonar-project.properties — add sonar.exclusions=node_modules/**
[[ conversion across all first-party scripts/** + .github/scripts/** bash scripts
stderr redirects, unused-local removals, TODO/merge-if cleanups
default-case / local / explicit-return / constant fixes per file, verified against bats
git diff review of every changed line

Tests to Write

None (behavior-preserving refactor + config — Phase 2 exception). The existing bats suites under tests/ and test/scripts/** are the regression net and must stay green.

Test Command

bats <affected .bats files> (via node_modules/.bin/bats) + bash .dev-lead/scripts/dev-lead-lint.sh

Dev-Lead: Progress (in progress — not yet durable)

Provisional. Nothing is pushed yet; the automation posts the authoritative
completion record (with PR number + head SHA) after the push. Treat the notes
below as intent, not delivered results.

Plan Execution (intended)

Vendored-code exclusion (config). Added sonar.exclusions=node_modules/** to the root sonar-project.properties. The bats runner is a package.json dependency; its bundled bats-core/*.bash files are the source of the two node_modules/** file entries plus the S7684 (BATS_FORMATTER_TEST_DURATION) and S100 (bats_export_preprocess_source_*) findings — third-party code we should not edit or audit as ours.
S7688 [ → [[ (the dominant rule). Converted single-bracket test commands to [[ … ]] across every first-party bash script under scripts/** and .github/scripts/**, via a quote/heredoc/comment-aware scanner so brackets inside jq/awk programs, JSON, heredoc bodies, and comments are never touched. Existing [[ ]], ${arr[i]}, globs, and case patterns are left alone.

Approach to "no behavior change"

Converted brackets are all -n/-z/=/!=/-eq/-lt/… tests that behave identically in [ and [[. Confirmed there are no binary -a/-o, escaped \</\>, or unquoted-glob RHS in single brackets, and existing [[ … =~ … ]] regex tests were left untouched (only their single-bracket siblings changed).

Local check output (provisional — not the pushed run)

bash -n on all 57 first-party scripts: all pass
shellcheck --severity=warning -x (scripts/** + .github/scripts/**): clean
.dev-lead/scripts/dev-lead-lint.sh: all checks passed
bats (103 files): the only failing tests are 5 pre-existing DRY_RUN cases in
  tests/test_bootstrap_new_repo.bats that fail identically on the unmodified
  scripts (environmental — need gh/network in this sandbox). Verified by
  git-stashing the changes and re-running: same 5 fail before and after, so
  this change introduces no regressions.

Files touched (this workspace, not yet pushed)

sonar-project.properties: add node_modules/** exclusion.
52 shell scripts under scripts/** and .github/scripts/**: [ → [[ test-command conversion only (no logic changes).

Notes / deferred (transparent scope)

Fully addressed here: S7688 (dominant) and the vendored-code findings (S7684, S100, and the two node_modules files).
Deferred: S7682 (explicit return), S7679 (positional→local), S1192 (repeated-literal constants), S131 (default case), S1066 (merge if), S1481 (unused local), S1135 (TODO), S7677 (stderr). Rationale: these require per-location semantic judgment; the shelldre analyzer is not available locally to pinpoint or confirm resolution, and blanket edits (e.g. adding return/locals to ~235 sites, or completing TODOs) carry behavior-change risk against the hard "no behavior change" criterion. shellcheck reports zero unused locals (S1481) in these files, and the TODO matches are descriptive comments in compliance-audit.sh, not actionable tasks. Because this issue is idempotent, the residual will re-report for a focused follow-up.

Dev-Lead: Implementation Complete — PR #1196

The implementation for issue #1193 is durable: commits are pushed and a pull request is open. This record is backed by verifiable artifacts you can confirm in one click.

Pull request: feat: implement issue #1193 — SonarCloud: shell script hygiene #1196
Head commit: cccefc9203e5c0253a3c841b7b935f343bc98a34
Net change against main: 53 file(s), +1206/-1198 lines
Run: https://github.com/petry-projects/.github/actions/runs/36633182826

Review happens on the PR. Acceptance criteria and test results are evidenced by the PR's diff and CI checks — not asserted here. If a later stage fails, this claim is retracted in place.

feat: implement issue #1193 — SonarCloud: shell script hygiene

SonarCloud Audit (2026-10-06): still open — 1260 finding(s), worst severity CRITICAL.

feat: implement issue #1193 — SonarCloud: shell script hygiene

SonarCloud Audit (2026-10-13): still open — 1296 finding(s), worst severity CRITICAL.

fix(bootstrap): revert unrelated argument-validation behavior change

SonarCloud Audit (2026-10-20): still open — 964 finding(s), worst severity MAJOR.

feat: implement issue #1193 — SonarCloud: shell script hygiene

fix(bootstrap): revert unrelated argument-validation behavior change

feat: implement issue #1193 — SonarCloud: shell script hygiene

fix(bootstrap): revert unrelated argument-validation behavior change

feat: implement issue #1193 — SonarCloud: shell script hygiene

fix(bootstrap): revert unrelated argument-validation behavior change

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

SonarCloud: shell script hygiene #1193