Add Meta Seal watermarking algorithms (PixelSeal, ChunkySeal, VideoSeal, AudioSeal, TextSeal)#48
Add Meta Seal watermarking algorithms (PixelSeal, ChunkySeal, VideoSeal, AudioSeal, TextSeal)#48carlreid wants to merge 6 commits intoc2pa-org:mainfrom
Conversation
jcollomosse
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
In light of submission policy:
The PR shall be submitted by an individual affiliated with the company owning the submitted proprietary algorithm or a maintainer of the submitted open source algorithm or its fork.
please can you confirm that you have permission from Meta to register entries within the meta.com namespace.
|
Ah, I've emailed Regarding the policy quoted policy. On what grounds did #43 get approved? Would that count as a fork? Though as far as I can read, it's essentially a service utilizing these Meta models as is? |
|
@carlreid indeed #43 is a for of an open-source WM algorithm. The fork is what was submitted and this is complying with our policy:
Feel free to join the watermarking task force if you'd like to contribute and discuss the approach. |
|
Thanks for the insight @domguinard.
Would that be via https://lists.c2pa.org/g/twg? |
Registers some of the open source watermarking algorithms from Meta Seal suite as soft binding algorithms for C2PA:
com.meta.pixelseal.1com.meta.chunkyseal.1com.meta.videoseal.1com.meta.audioseal.1com.meta.textseal.1I noticed the
com.aiwatermarkrelated entries, which appears to be a paid service exposing these same models. If I understand things correctly, then this algorithm list is to be used as a list of potential watermark implementations that would be required to detect all potential cases of content using a C2PA Soft Binding? Which leaves me a little concerned that it could lead to many paid providers re-exposing open source models, such that ultimately the C2PA manifest can't be discovered without paying for access. It seems a little counter intuitive to define an interoperable Soft Binding API spec, yet providers can register here behind paywalls.I have also included an additional fix in
README.mdfromsoftbinding-algorithm-list-schema.jsontosoftbinding-algorithm-list.schema.json.