Document model routing and outcome observation

[WJiangH]

Deliverable manifest

Role: orchestrator framework author
Work item: ORCH-MODEL-ROUTING-01 — record difficulty-based model/effort selection and complete-loop outcome observation in orchestrator assignments
Delivery state: Merged — root merged exact approved head 3c10dc1d2d66a5207111eb0963338f46624dcf69 as 15553cbf46d9b83bdf14b3a2447092c6ddb2dd81 at 2026-09-12T04:19:20Z
Runtime requested: gpt-5.6-terra / medium
Runtime observed: UNKNOWN / none / UNKNOWN
Provenance: ORCH-MODEL-ROUTING-01; make attribution-validate and range validation PASS for 3c10dc1d2d66a5207111eb0963338f46624dcf69
Platform publisher: branch push completed to origin/framework/orchestrator-model-routing; pusher identity remains UNKNOWN to attribution validation
CI state: required exact-head checks completed PASS: boundaries, framework, and gates; prior pr-review=SUCCESS; mention, role-dispatch, and delivery skipped. Ready-triggered Agents pr-review run 34672673651 remains IN_PROGRESS.

Artifacts:

• .agents/skills/orchestrator/SKILL.md — records selection dimensions, proportional configuration choice, delivery-loop observations, and safe configuration changes.
• .agents/skills/orchestrator/references/operating.md — makes model decision and outcome fields part of the formal assignment/return record.
• docs/templates/ORCHESTRATION_STATE.md — preserves those assignment, return, comparison, and handoff records in private state.

Applicable checks:

• make framework-test — PASS: 51 framework tests, 20 source tests, 16 boundary checks, documentation 78 documents / 131 links / 0 errors
• make attribution-validate — PASS for 3c10dc1d2d66a5207111eb0963338f46624dcf69
• make attribution-validate-range ATTRIBUTION_BASE=origin/main ATTRIBUTION_SOURCE=HEAD — PASS: one structured commit validated
• git diff --check origin/main...HEAD — PASS

Not run:

• lint, simulation, formal, synthesis, coverage, and software — framework method/template-only change; no product artifacts changed

Spec / policy refs:

• AGENTS.md branch lifecycle, publication boundary, and provenance rules
• .agents/skills/orchestrator/SKILL.md and references/operating.md

Lifecycle impact:

• Not applicable: framework-only documentation and private-state template update; no product signoff claim.
• Independently authorized N/A: none.

Publication audit:

• Public base: origin/main at 53fc51747a305ba037f29c17e3b2e893293002ca
• Outgoing ancestry: 3c10dc1 Document difficulty-based model routing and outcome observation for orchestrator assignments
• Aggregate diff: only the three artifacts above; no private inputs or local evidence included

Independent review:

• APPROVE for exact head 3c10dc1d2d66a5207111eb0963338f46624dcf69: Document model routing and outcome observation #40 (comment). All findings resolved.

Integration / retirement:

• Merged by root as 15553cbf46d9b83bdf14b3a2447092c6ddb2dd81. Retain the feature branch/worktree and private receipts while Ready-triggered Agents pr-review run 34672673651 is IN_PROGRESS; original author will inspect its terminal result before safe retirement.

Open items:

• Post-merge Agents pr-review run 34672673651 is IN_PROGRESS. Branch/worktree cleanup is blocked pending its terminal result and retained-evidence check.

Friction:

• Earlier post-create API/DNS readback failed; PR Document model routing and outcome observation #40 was delivered and later independently confirmed.

Skill candidates:

• none

[claude]

Integrator check on reviewed head 3c10dc1d2d66a5207111eb0963338f46624dcf69: live head matches, but the PR is currently Draft. Per integration checklist, Draft PRs are not eligible for merge review completion — exiting without merging. No further action taken; the author/@WJiangH marks it Ready when it's intended for merge.

[WJiangH]

REQUEST_CHANGES — substantive independent integrator review of exact head 3c10dc1d2d66a5207111eb0963338f46624dcf69 against base 53fc51747a305ba037f29c17e3b2e893293002ca.

1. The deliverable manifest is stale after CI completed. The PR body still says Delivery state: Draft — independent integrator review and CI remain pending, CI state: pending, and lists CI as an open item, while the live check rollup for this exact head now shows boundaries, framework, and gates all SUCCESS. Update those manifest fields to the observed CI result and record this substantive request-changes verdict/re-review as the remaining review item. The integrator method requires the manifest to match rerun gate results (.agents/skills/integrator/SKILL.md lines 8–13); the constitution leaves manifest correction and re-review with the original author (AGENTS.md lines 55–65). No source change is requested.

Source and evidence review otherwise passed: the aggregate diff is one commit and exactly the three assigned framework paths; it records all required model-decision inputs, configured model/effort plus rationale, intended independent reviewer, bounded escalation/continuation, complete-loop observations and unknowns, comparable-scope limits, and supported-switch/handoff ownership rules. No product/spec/gate-threshold change is present. Independent clean-candidate reruns passed: skill validation (Skill is valid!), git diff --check, commit and one-commit range attribution validation, and make framework-test (51 framework tests, 20 source tests, 16 boundary checks, docs 78 documents / 131 links / 0 errors). Hardware, model, DUT, compiler, lint, simulation, formal, synthesis, coverage, and software runs were not applicable to this documentation-only diff.

The earlier automation comment only reported Draft status; it was not substantive approval. Keep the PR Draft and request re-review after the manifest is synchronized.

[WJiangH]

APPROVE — substantive manifest re-review of exact head 3c10dc1d2d66a5207111eb0963338f46624dcf69 against base 53fc51747a305ba037f29c17e3b2e893293002ca.

The sole prior request-changes finding is resolved. The corrected manifest now reports the live exact-head results accurately: boundaries, framework, gates, and pr-review are SUCCESS; mention, role-dispatch, and delivery are skipped. It records the completed CI state and identifies this re-review as the only pending item, which is accurate through this verdict.

The PR head and source diff are unchanged, so the prior independent source review and clean-candidate checks remain applicable without rerun. The source verdict remains PASS: one outgoing commit, exactly the three authorized framework paths, no product/spec/gate-threshold changes, and no unsupported model identity or ranking claim.

No unresolved substantive findings remain for this exact candidate. Keep lifecycle synchronization, any Ready transition, merge, and cleanup with their separately authorized owners.

[claude]

Integrator spot-check on reviewed head 3c10dc1d2d66a5207111eb0963338f46624dcf69: PR is already MERGED (merge commit 15553cbf46d9b83bdf14b3a2447092c6ddb2dd81, merged by @WJiangH at 2026-09-12T04:19:20Z) at exactly that head — no merge action taken here.

Retrospective checks:

• Required checks on that head: boundaries pass, framework pass, gates pass (gh pr checks 40 --required).
• Boundary: diff touches only .agents/skills/orchestrator/SKILL.md, .agents/skills/orchestrator/references/operating.md, docs/templates/ORCHESTRATION_STATE.md — orchestrator's own method/reference and the shared state template, within the orchestrator framework-author role (AGENTS.md role table + "Framework work belongs to a named framework author").
• Gate integrity: no edits to flow/gates.mk, .sdc, or any threshold/waiver/test skip.
• Spec conformance: N/A — framework method doc only, no product/spec claim.
• Evidence: re-ran make framework-test independently — 51 framework tests OK, 16 boundary checks ok 1..16, docs PASS (78 documents, 131 local links, 0 errors) — matches the manifest's claimed numbers.
• Review thread: the sole REQUEST_CHANGES finding (stale manifest CI/delivery-state fields) was resolved and followed by an independent APPROVE on the same exact head; manifest now matches merged state.

No unresolved findings. Nothing further required.