What is wrong
Scotland's working-age Council Tax Reduction scheme defines a "young person" as a Universal Credit qualifying young person. The model uses the Child Benefit definition for every scheme: council_tax_reduction_applicable_amount decides lone-parent status with is_lone_parent, and council_tax_reduction_applicable_income counts the income of is_child_or_young_person_for_legacy_benefits members. Both follow the Child Benefit qualifying young person.
The two definitions differ. For example, a 19-year-old on a non-advanced course begun before 19 is a Child Benefit qualifying young person until 20 (Child Benefit (General) Regulations 2006 reg. 3), but a Universal Credit one only until the 1 September after their 19th birthday (UC Regs 2013 reg. 5(1)(b)).
On main (9475c95), 2026-27, a single claimant aged 22 in Edinburgh, not on Universal Credit, with a 19-year-old at school who is past that 1 September and earns £2,000:
council_tax_reduction_applicable_amount = £4,968.60, the lone parent allowance (£95.55 × 52). It should be £3,933.80, the single under-25 allowance (£75.65 × 52).
council_tax_reduction_applicable_income = £3,406.60, which counts the 19-year-old's £2,000. It should be £1,406.60.
The law
Council Tax Reduction (Scotland) Regulations 2021 (SSI 2021/249), in force 1 April 2022 (reg. 1):
- Reg. 6(1): "In these Regulations “young person” means a person who falls within the definition of “qualifying young person” in regulation 5 of the 2013 Regulations (meaning of qualifying young person)." Reg. 4 defines "the 2013 Regulations" as the Universal Credit Regulations 2013.
- Reg. 4: "“lone parent” means a person who has no partner and who is responsible for and a member of the same household as a child or young person".
- Reg. 7(2)-(3): "A person is responsible for a child or young person who normally lives with them. But a person is not responsible for a young person if the two of them are living as a couple."
The other schemes keep the Child Benefit definition, so they are right today:
Fix
Give Council Tax Reduction its own child-or-young-person flag: the Universal Credit test in Scotland's working-age scheme from 2022-23, and the legacy (Child Benefit) flag elsewhere. Read it for lone-parent status in the applicable amount and for the members whose income counts.
Found as a follow-up to #2279. #1966 (draft) builds new Scottish working-age variables on is_lone_parent and the legacy flag; it should read the new flag once this lands.
What is wrong
Scotland's working-age Council Tax Reduction scheme defines a "young person" as a Universal Credit qualifying young person. The model uses the Child Benefit definition for every scheme:
council_tax_reduction_applicable_amountdecides lone-parent status withis_lone_parent, andcouncil_tax_reduction_applicable_incomecounts the income ofis_child_or_young_person_for_legacy_benefitsmembers. Both follow the Child Benefit qualifying young person.The two definitions differ. For example, a 19-year-old on a non-advanced course begun before 19 is a Child Benefit qualifying young person until 20 (Child Benefit (General) Regulations 2006 reg. 3), but a Universal Credit one only until the 1 September after their 19th birthday (UC Regs 2013 reg. 5(1)(b)).
On
main(9475c95), 2026-27, a single claimant aged 22 in Edinburgh, not on Universal Credit, with a 19-year-old at school who is past that 1 September and earns £2,000:council_tax_reduction_applicable_amount= £4,968.60, the lone parent allowance (£95.55 × 52). It should be £3,933.80, the single under-25 allowance (£75.65 × 52).council_tax_reduction_applicable_income= £3,406.60, which counts the 19-year-old's £2,000. It should be £1,406.60.The law
Council Tax Reduction (Scotland) Regulations 2021 (SSI 2021/249), in force 1 April 2022 (reg. 1):
The other schemes keep the Child Benefit definition, so they are right today:
Fix
Give Council Tax Reduction its own child-or-young-person flag: the Universal Credit test in Scotland's working-age scheme from 2022-23, and the legacy (Child Benefit) flag elsewhere. Read it for lone-parent status in the applicable amount and for the members whose income counts.
Found as a follow-up to #2279. #1966 (draft) builds new Scottish working-age variables on
is_lone_parentand the legacy flag; it should read the new flag once this lands.