Conversation
autogame-17
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Reviewed head a72dd6ea19b9b00559f31e58b39813a940fda7bd. Please address the following before inclusion:
README.md:193bypasses the canonical data source. The PR only inserts Ivy Tendril insideAUTOGEN:prompt-optimization; there is no corresponding record indata/projects.json. On an untouched checkout, Node 24.19.0 actually reports:RunningValidated 119 projects across 10 categories Validation failed with 1 error(s): - README is not reproducible from data/projects.jsonnode scripts/generate-readme.jsthen removes exactly that one line (230 bytes). A subsequent validator pass is green only because the proposed entry has disappeared. Please add a schema-valid JSON record first and regenerate README, as required by CONTRIBUTING. The link checker also reads JSON only, so its result does not cover this README-only URL.- The “Open-source” claim does not match the current license. The canonical upstream README explicitly says “source-available”, and its LICENSE is FSL-1.1-ALv2 with a competing-use restriction. Apache-2.0 is a future per-version grant after two years, not the current unrestricted license. Please accurately disclose FSL/source-available status in both the entry and PR body so maintainers can assess inclusion; GitHub's
NOASSERTIONalone was not used as evidence. - The placement does not match the described capability. This change lands in Prompt and Behaviour Optimization, not the Multi-Agent Frameworks section named in the PR title. Upstream documents coding-agent worktrees, code review and verification gates, not prompt optimization. Please justify an appropriate category (
codingfits the documented software-engineering workspace); if the primary contribution you want to list is team/swarm orchestration, use the sibling swarm list instead. Use an objective description rather than “an amazing UI”.
The current branch also conflicts with latest upstream main (696251db2101902baf98e78899ca195d3d2c6f42) in README. Refresh from upstream, resolve the JSON/source-of-truth change, and regenerate rather than hand-editing the generated block.
Validate the updated committed content with:
node scripts/generate-readme.js
node scripts/validate.js
git diff --check
node scripts/check-links.jsSeparate baseline issue: the full link check returned 118 ok, 1 failure, 0 warnings, with an HTTP 404 for existing Fzkuji/OpenProgram; that is not an Ivy URL failure and is not a request to remove unrelated entries. Ivy's canonical repository itself was accessible, active, documented, and not archived. The current validate workflow is action_required with 0 jobs; it has not executed the validator and must not be treated as passing.
Summary
Adds Ivy Tendril to the section.
About Ivy Tendril
Checklist