Your library should be split into several NuGet packages

[bohdan-bats-bs]

Currently, I only need ContextMenu from DIPS.Mobile.UI, but I have to add all your code, and as a result, size of my application will increase significantly.

I suggest to split DIPS.Mobile.UI into several NuGet packages.

[haavamoa]

Thanks for the suggestion!

At this time, splitting DIPS.Mobile.UI into multiple smaller NuGet packages isn’t something we plan to prioritize. The library is designed and released as a single cohesive package that provides a complete set of UI components and design resources aimed at supporting developers building DIPS mobile apps. The expectation is that consumers of the library install and use it as a whole, rather than pulling out individual parts.

That said, if this becomes a broader need from multiple users in the future, we can revisit the idea.

It's interesting that your application grew significantly, how much in size did it grow exactly? We aim at trimming away code that should not be used, but I can see that icons etc from our design system might be the reason it grows. If this is the case, then maybe we can see if we can split out the parts that actually takes up most of the extra size.

[yevgeny-sotnikov]

Thanks for the suggestion!

At this time, splitting DIPS.Mobile.UI into multiple smaller NuGet packages isn’t something we plan to prioritize. The library is designed and released as a single cohesive package that provides a complete set of UI components and design resources aimed at supporting developers building DIPS mobile apps. The expectation is that consumers of the library install and use it as a whole, rather than pulling out individual parts.

That said, if this becomes a broader need from multiple users in the future, we can revisit the idea.

It's interesting that your application grew significantly, how much in size did it grow exactly? We aim at trimming away code that should not be used, but I can see that icons etc from our design system might be the reason it grows. If this is the case, then maybe we can see if we can split out the parts that actually takes up most of the extra size.

@haavamoa personally i got error of conflict with svg images after adding your nuget to my project, this is only one of many:

Microsoft.Maui.Resizetizer.After.targets(633,9): Error : One or more duplicate file names were detected. All image output filenames must be unique: alert_line (/Users/yevgeny/.nuget/packages/dips.mobile.ui/55.6.7/buildTransitive/Resources/Icons/alert_line.svg)

So your package contains many of icons which conflicts with another packages and codebase

[haavamoa]

Thanks for the suggestion!
At this time, splitting DIPS.Mobile.UI into multiple smaller NuGet packages isn’t something we plan to prioritize. The library is designed and released as a single cohesive package that provides a complete set of UI components and design resources aimed at supporting developers building DIPS mobile apps. The expectation is that consumers of the library install and use it as a whole, rather than pulling out individual parts.
That said, if this becomes a broader need from multiple users in the future, we can revisit the idea.
It's interesting that your application grew significantly, how much in size did it grow exactly? We aim at trimming away code that should not be used, but I can see that icons etc from our design system might be the reason it grows. If this is the case, then maybe we can see if we can split out the parts that actually takes up most of the extra size.

@haavamoa personally i got error of conflict with svg images after adding your nuget to my project, this is only one of many:

Microsoft.Maui.Resizetizer.After.targets(633,9): Error : One or more duplicate file names were detected. All image output filenames must be unique: alert_line (/Users/yevgeny/.nuget/packages/dips.mobile.ui/55.6.7/buildTransitive/Resources/Icons/alert_line.svg)

So your package containg many of icons which conflicts with another packages and codebase

I see, can you try this approach to turn it off?

[Vetle444]

Thanks for the suggestion!
At this time, splitting DIPS.Mobile.UI into multiple smaller NuGet packages isn’t something we plan to prioritize. The library is designed and released as a single cohesive package that provides a complete set of UI components and design resources aimed at supporting developers building DIPS mobile apps. The expectation is that consumers of the library install and use it as a whole, rather than pulling out individual parts.
That said, if this becomes a broader need from multiple users in the future, we can revisit the idea.
It's interesting that your application grew significantly, how much in size did it grow exactly? We aim at trimming away code that should not be used, but I can see that icons etc from our design system might be the reason it grows. If this is the case, then maybe we can see if we can split out the parts that actually takes up most of the extra size.

@haavamoa personally i got error of conflict with svg images after adding your nuget to my project, this is only one of many:

Microsoft.Maui.Resizetizer.After.targets(633,9): Error : One or more duplicate file names were detected. All image output filenames must be unique: alert_line (/Users/yevgeny/.nuget/packages/dips.mobile.ui/55.6.7/buildTransitive/Resources/Icons/alert_line.svg)

So your package containg many of icons which conflicts with another packages and codebase

Or rather <ResizetizerErrorOnDuplicateOutputFilename>false</ResizetizerErrorOnDuplicateOutputFilename> if you need our icons.

[yevgeny-sotnikov]

Thanks for the suggestion!
At this time, splitting DIPS.Mobile.UI into multiple smaller NuGet packages isn’t something we plan to prioritize. The library is designed and released as a single cohesive package that provides a complete set of UI components and design resources aimed at supporting developers building DIPS mobile apps. The expectation is that consumers of the library install and use it as a whole, rather than pulling out individual parts.
That said, if this becomes a broader need from multiple users in the future, we can revisit the idea.
It's interesting that your application grew significantly, how much in size did it grow exactly? We aim at trimming away code that should not be used, but I can see that icons etc from our design system might be the reason it grows. If this is the case, then maybe we can see if we can split out the parts that actually takes up most of the extra size.

@haavamoa personally i got error of conflict with svg images after adding your nuget to my project, this is only one of many:
Microsoft.Maui.Resizetizer.After.targets(633,9): Error : One or more duplicate file names were detected. All image output filenames must be unique: alert_line (/Users/yevgeny/.nuget/packages/dips.mobile.ui/55.6.7/buildTransitive/Resources/Icons/alert_line.svg)
So your package containg many of icons which conflicts with another packages and codebase

I see, can you try this approach to turn it off?

@haavamoa tried - I added it to cross-laltform csproj and to platform-specific scproj files - error still exist

[yevgeny-sotnikov]

Thanks for the suggestion!
At this time, splitting DIPS.Mobile.UI into multiple smaller NuGet packages isn’t something we plan to prioritize. The library is designed and released as a single cohesive package that provides a complete set of UI components and design resources aimed at supporting developers building DIPS mobile apps. The expectation is that consumers of the library install and use it as a whole, rather than pulling out individual parts.
That said, if this becomes a broader need from multiple users in the future, we can revisit the idea.
It's interesting that your application grew significantly, how much in size did it grow exactly? We aim at trimming away code that should not be used, but I can see that icons etc from our design system might be the reason it grows. If this is the case, then maybe we can see if we can split out the parts that actually takes up most of the extra size.

@haavamoa personally i got error of conflict with svg images after adding your nuget to my project, this is only one of many:
Microsoft.Maui.Resizetizer.After.targets(633,9): Error : One or more duplicate file names were detected. All image output filenames must be unique: alert_line (/Users/yevgeny/.nuget/packages/dips.mobile.ui/55.6.7/buildTransitive/Resources/Icons/alert_line.svg)
So your package containg many of icons which conflicts with another packages and codebase

Or rather <ResizetizerErrorOnDuplicateOutputFilename>false</ResizetizerErrorOnDuplicateOutputFilename> if you need our icons.

@Vetle444 same as topic starter - i need to use only context menu, nothing more, so icons aren't needed